← Lost New York
LOST NEW YORK · THE TEMPLE NEW YORK THREW AWAY

Pennsylvania Station

For half a century a Roman bath stood over the rail yards of Manhattan; in 1963 the city began feeding it, column by column, into a New Jersey swamp.

“One entered the city like a god; one scuttles in now like a rat.” — Vincent Scully, art historian

In April 1902 the president of the Pennsylvania Railroad, Alexander Cassatt, sent a telegram to the architect Charles Follen McKim, and set in motion the most ambitious act of civic architecture the United States had yet attempted. McKim, of McKim, Mead & White, did not design a train station. He designed an entrance — a monument through which a nation would arrive at its largest city. The New York Board of Aldermen approved the plans that December by the narrowest of votes, 41 to 36. Excavation of more than three million cubic yards of Manhattan schist began in 1904; stonework rose from 1908; and on November 27, 1910, the full Pennsylvania Station opened to the public. McKim himself did not live to see it finished — his health failing, he had withdrawn in 1906, and William Symmes Richardson carried the design to completion.

What opened covered roughly eight acres, the whole superblock between Seventh and Eighth Avenues and 31st and 33rd Streets — 788 feet along the side streets, 432 along the avenues. Its outer walls wore pink Milford granite, quarried in Massachusetts and hauled to the site in the railroad’s own cars. The great waiting room ran 314 feet long and rose 150 feet to its coffered vaults, its lower walls sheathed in Italian travertine — a hall consciously modeled on the vaulted immensity of imperial Roman baths. Beyond it, in deliberate contrast, lay the concourse: not masonry but a soaring lattice of steel and glass over the platforms, the machine age standing frankly beside the classical.

How does a thing like this die? Not by catastrophe, but by arithmetic. The Pennsylvania Railroad booked its first operating losses in 1947, and a granite temple costs a fortune merely to sweep and heat. The railroad had optioned the station’s air rights as early as 1954. In 1962 the plan became public: a developer would raze the head house and build a new Madison Square Garden and an office tower above the tracks. Architects picketed — the Action Group for Better Architecture in New York rallied in August 1962 — but the city cleared the way, and on October 28, 1963, the wreckers began. The work ground on until 1966. The carved columns and the allegorical sculptures were carted across the Hudson and dumped in a landfill in the New Jersey Meadowlands.

The outrage did not save the building. It did something larger: it changed the law. New York City passed its Landmarks Preservation Law in April 1965, creating the Landmarks Preservation Commission with power to designate and protect. Penn Station’s destruction is the loss most often named as the birth of the modern American preservation movement — though honest historians caution the movement was already stirring before the first column fell. The replacement opened, and generations of travelers have since descended into its low ceilings. The lesson the city drew was not that it had lost a station. It was that it had been capable of losing one.

What went to the landfill

Pink Milford granite across four great elevations (contemporary records cite ~490,000 cubic feet); Italian travertine lining the waiting room; on the order of 27,000 short tons of structural steel spanning the glass-and-steel concourse; and the bronze of the grilles, clocks and fittings.